Featuring Mike Feazel, co-founder and CEO of Roof Maxx.
When Google pushed AI Overviews to the top of search, Roof Maxx watched its average cost per lead jump from about $350 to well over $600. Mike Feazel shut off national marketing for the first time in three years, rebuilt the program from scratch, and told his dealers to get back on the doors. His answer to an AI-driven lead crisis is to own more of the homeowner relationship, from annual maintenance to replacement, and to build demand that does not run through a search box.
Mike Feazel has been in roofing for 40 years. He and his brother Todd started Feazel Roofing in Columbus, Ohio, in the mid-1980s and built it into one of the larger roofing companies in the country. They sold it in 2013 and went on to create a product category that did not exist: roof rejuvenation.
Today Roof Maxx has more than 300 dealers and over 20,000 reviews at a 4.9-star average. I brought Mike on the show because he had just lived through that crisis, and every decision he made landed on 300 dealers.
Build the category the big roofers walked past
The formula came from outside roofing. Its makers first built the soybean-based product for asphalt roads, and a few people had tried it on shingles without much luck selling it.
"The patent had pretty much sat on the shelf for nearly two decades. There was only about three and a half years left when we got the rights to the formulation."
Since then, Mike and Todd have worked with the Ohio Soybean Council, Battelle, and Ohio State University on a second-generation patent. Selling it was the harder problem from day one. The people best positioned to sell it wanted nothing to do with it.
"Roofing contractors didn't want to become a Roof Maxx dealer. Most roofers replace roofs or they might do repairs. There really wasn't this maintenance model in the middle."
So Roof Maxx recruited business opportunity seekers instead and built demand with TV and radio. Years later, the network is made up of contractors who understand roofing. About 80% of dealers now offer replacement or work with a referral partner.
Mike points to commercial roofing as the template. Large property owners hire asset managers who inspect, maintain, repair, restore, and only then replace. Residential roofing is moving toward the same model, and Roof Maxx built its business in the middle of that model.
Plan for the storm already hitting roofing
I asked Mike why so many roofers are suddenly interested in maintenance. He called it a perfect storm. Leads are harder to get, and insurance work is shrinking fast.
"It used to be 3% of roofs got replaced by insurance, and then it got to 33%. Well, they're getting that genie back in the bottle, and it might end up at 8% or 10%, but that market is dying."
Carriers are moving homeowners to actual cash value policies, which pay a prorated amount instead of a free roof. Mike compares it to paint. Nobody waits for the paint to peel and then calls the insurance company, and he expects homeowners to treat the roof the same way.
The third force is the zero-click crisis, where homeowners get an AI overview answer on Google and never actually click on a contractor's website.
Private equity has also heavily occupied the roofing space in recent years. Mike estimates private equity owns about 30% of HVAC companies, and those companies run on annual maintenance plans that lead to the big replacement sale. He expects the same in roofing. An annual inspection package, rejuvenation in the middle of the roof's life, then replacement or a roof-and-solar package at the end.
If your company only makes money on the last step, you are fighting every other roofer for the same replacement jobs. On the show, I pointed to Owl Roofing, the company Tim Brown of Hook Agency runs with his partner. Their team takes the small jobs on purpose so homeowners experience the brand first. Tim Brown explains how he builds local dominance in our interview on contractor local dominance.
Assess the roof, then sell what the customer needs
A maintenance-first company only works if homeowners trust the recommendation. Mike tells his dealers, and any contractor, the same thing.
"Our job is not to go out and tell a customer what they need. Our job is to go out and assess the roof and determine what is going on and then find out what the customer needs."
He gave three examples of how that plays out.
- Selling the home next summer: a tune-up, tight gutters, and a cleaning. Skip the treatment.
- Selling, roof will raise questions: a treatment and a five-year guarantee you can pass to the buyer.
- Past saving: a full replacement at $20,000 to $30,000. Nobody likes to hear it, but some homeowners need to.
Mike is just as honest about the product's limits. Bad decking or failing flashings mean rejuvenation does nothing. In his words, Roof Maxx "is not a magic bullet." You need a structurally sound roof first.
Build one brand, then lease the territory
Roof Maxx looks like a franchise from the outside. Dealers wear the brand and wrap their trucks in it. But there is no franchise fee. Dealers buy the product.
Mike got advice from a friend who helped build the Renewal by Andersen dealer model. He did not want the regulation that comes with franchising. He did want a national brand. Most dealer models sell an unbranded product, like a gutter cover the installer sells under his own name. Mike felt rejuvenation was too new for that and had to be sold under one brand.
Roof Maxx spent just over $20 million on advertising in a single year, much of it TV aimed at homeowners over 50. Surveys put Roof Maxx at 24% name recognition nationwide. Mike says no national roofer has a household name.
Dealers lease their territory for as long as they stay in the network. When Roof Maxx takes a territory off the market for a dealer, that dealer commits to buying a set amount of product for it. Mike calls it "a very simple agreement."
Shut off spend when the math breaks
Before the change, Roof Maxx was sending about 2,500 leads a week to dealers. Then Google went all in on AI Overviews.
For years, a homeowner who saw a Roof Maxx TV ad would search the name, click an ad or the website, and land on a page the team had split-tested from a 3% conversion rate up to 8%. That page stopped being the first thing people saw.
"Now, all of a sudden, it shows up with this random, basically landing page thing called an AI overview that was not very accurate. It said that our reviews were polarized."
Roof Maxx averages 4.9 stars across more than 20,000 reviews. Mike says the AI has since gotten smarter. It now reads the split correctly: homeowners love Roof Maxx, and contractors who sell replacements question it.
Before the show, his team described lead costs that had almost gone up tenfold. Mike corrected that on the record.
"Our lead cost went from average in the 350 range to well over 600. It didn't 10x, but it doubled and even tripled in some markets to the point where we had to shut off our national marketing and we had not done that for three years."
They kept it off for months, built a new national program on a new lead platform, and tuned it again after launch. Leads are climbing back. Mike expects to return to 2,500 a week by the following spring if the algorithm holds still.
Other companies took the same hit. Mike told me about a national flooring company that did $90 million in EBITDA one year and $7 million the next.
"The biggest change in 40 years for me in home services is the last 12 months."
Put your people back on the doors
Mike started his first roofing company with his dad's borrowed ladder on top of his car, knocking doors. Forty years later, door-to-door is the one channel he trusts to survive the AI shift.
"There has to be a better way, and right now the only thing I know that's not going to get disrupted is doors."
Mike still wants dealers to market. He also wants dealers to walk the street after every finished job. Introduce yourself to the neighbors, hand them a card, and tell them they will see you in the neighborhood.
Roofers used to sell a lot of roofs door-to-door, and Mike says it still works. Dashaun Bryant made a similar case in our conversation on door-to-door roofing sales.
Teach the AI who you are
Mike's biggest frustration with AI search is how it labels Roof Maxx.
"AI right now sees us as a product, and I don't want to be seen as a product."
He wants it to see a network of contractors. Large language models crawl and read long-form conversations like this one. Mike told me he came on the show to help train those models on what Roof Maxx is, how the business model works, and what the company is trying to do.
Roof Maxx also changed how it uses data.
"A lot of marketing is in the rear view mirror. What happened last week, last month, and you're trying to adjust. So now we're using AI so that we can look through the windshield into the future."
The team uses AI to forecast which messages will grab attention, then split-tests landing pages and pay-per-click ads against that forecast. That work helped bring lead costs back down. Lane Houk covers the search side of this shift in our piece on AI local search for home services.
Let good people leave on good terms
Roof Maxx has copycats, including some who make warranty claims Mike says they cannot back with testing. He does not take it personally. When he started out, he followed everything Able Roofing did, because everybody in business does that.
Dealers leave too. One quit, sat out a three-year non-compete, and now runs a competitor. When other dealers ripped on him, Mike pushed back. Another recently closed his dealership to go work with Lance Bachmann. Mike told him to go for it. Kelly Mesaris, COO of Lance's LB Capital, explained their model in our interview on LB Capital's roofing blueprint.
"Why would I ever want to hold somebody back from something they're excited about?"
His reason goes back to his first job out of high school. Mike was living in his employer's home with the owner's son. When Mike started his own roofing company, the owner threw him out of the house.
Mike chose to run his own company the opposite way. In the early 1990s, he and Todd pulled a talented young roofer into the office and told him he could do more than climb roofs. Thirty-five years later, the man emailed Mike to say he is now sales manager of a $70 million company and wanted to thank him.
Mike put it plainly: "I don't think you can get to a certain size in business if you want to keep everybody back and hold them back."
What roofing owners should take from Mike's playbook
Mike's network took a real hit, and he is clear that dealers are still feeling it. These three moves are what he is betting on to come out ahead.
- Watch cost per lead and be ready to shut it off. Mike shut off national marketing once his cost per lead doubled, and in some markets tripled. He rebuilt the program before he restarted it.
- Own the homeowner across the whole life of the roof. Annual maintenance, rejuvenation, then replacement. In Mike's words, become "the roof asset manager, the lifetime contractor for that property owner and their friends and family."
- Build demand that does not run through search. Knock on the neighbors' doors after every job. Then publish long-form content so AI describes your company correctly when homeowners do search.
Watch the full conversation
Mike also covers how Roof Maxx protects dealers with non-competes, why he sees solar becoming part of the roofing package, and the advice he gave his nephew about failure. Watch the full Mike Feazel episode on YouTube, and learn more about the dealer program at Roof Maxx's dealer opportunity site.
If your team is losing leads to slow callbacks while lead costs climb, book a Nail demo to see how we answer every call and follow up on every lead.
Article by George Paladichuk, founder of Nail AI. Featuring Mike Feazel, co-founder and CEO of Roof Maxx.
Want NaiL to handle your missed calls?
See how AI can convert more of your leads into booked jobs — 24/7.
Book a Free Demo