By George Paladichuk, founder of NaiL. Adapted from my conversation with Tommy Mello on The Home Service Expert.
AI belongs behind your best phone rep, answering the calls your team misses. It does not belong on the first ring, and it never belongs on a call from someone in crisis. Roll it out with a clear story, real pilot results and a respected owner who vouches for it.
Tommy Mello founded A1 Garage Door Service and hosts The Home Service Expert, a podcast for home service owners. When he had me on the show in July 2026, he wanted to know where AI belongs on a home service company's phones, which is a question I deal with every day because my company answers the calls that franchise locations miss.
Count the calls nobody answers
Tommy started from his own numbers. A1 is in 25,000 homes a month and generates 34,000 leads, and he puts each lead's potential value at a couple thousand dollars, so at that volume every missed call costs real money. Most owners never see that cost, because call-tracking tools like CallRail and phone systems like RingCentral rarely report missed calls as lost revenue.
"It's a hidden metric, right? It doesn't really appear on any dashboard."
Superior Fence & Rail, the largest fence franchise in America, shows how big that hidden number gets. When one of its locations misses a call, the call rolls to us, and nearly 1,000 of those calls reach us every day. We answer, check the caller against that location's own rules and book the job onto the calendar of the franchisee, the local owner who runs that location. That brand now recovers $2 million to $2.5 million a month in revenue, tracked through to closed jobs.
Tommy tied this to Google Local Services Ads, the paid listings at the very top of Google search, where part of winning is answering on the first couple of rings. Missing those rings now costs even more, and I wrote about how Google now bills for missed calls.
Put your best rep on the phone and AI behind them
Tommy also looked at AI from the customer's side. He doesn't mind an AI agent when he calls his phone carrier about long-distance service while traveling abroad, but a broken pipe or a dead AC is different.
"I need to talk to somebody because my car's stuck or my pipe just broke or the AC unit's not working in the house."
I agree with him. Some companies that sell AI phone systems tell owners to replace every CSR, the customer service rep who answers the phones, and I called that "a bunch of craziness" on the show because consumers aren't there yet. AI does its best work as the backup.
"This should always be a safety net rather than the first touch if possible."
Our client data bears that out. When a person answers first and AI catches the rest, both booking rate (the share of callers who end up with a scheduled job) and CSAT (the customer satisfaction score) go up. Home service is personal, because your crew walks into a family's home, and if a homeowner can never reach a real person, trust drops.
Tommy already runs this model at scale. A1 has 70 full-time agents spread from the East Coast to the West Coast, covering 5 a.m. to 10 p.m., and there are still times when all 70 are on calls. Instead of a standard "press 1 for..." phone menu, known as an IVR, A1 built an AI version that sends "where's my door" and "I need to change my appointment" calls to someone who can help, so nobody gets tossed around and dumped into voicemail.
So staff your busiest hours with your best people and let AI catch the overflow. Lower cost is a bad reason to replace a rep, but it is a good reason not to hire more reps than you need. I wrote more about using AI as a safety net.
Keep AI off the calls people make in a crisis
Some calls should never reach AI at all. A contents restoration franchise, which cleans and repairs a family's belongings such as clothes, furniture and electronics after a fire or flood, asked me where AI fits in its business. After a long talk with the brand president, we agreed the first call is the wrong place for it, because that caller's house just burned down, flooded or got hit by a tornado.
"The last thing that person is gonna wanna hear on the other line is a robot."
Funeral homes fall in the same group, and I will never sell an AI receptionist to one. In businesses like these, real people around the clock can be worth the extra cost.
Compare offshore agents on coverage, not the hourly rate
Tommy asked about offshore agents, people in countries like the Philippines, Mexico or Israel who answer calls for U.S. companies, because he worried about the language barrier and about security. Many offshore agents sound great, but they are still people who take sick days and vacation and need sleep.
When we started with Superior Fence & Rail, the brand was looking at offshore agents, and that option cost the same or more while covering fewer hours. On busy days, calls hit the same location back to back, and a person can take only one of those calls at a time.
Eighteen months ago, I would have agreed with Tommy and told him to go offshore. However, AI voice quality has changed that fast. Over the summer, one of our voice providers went down for a few hours, and calls fell back to a year-old voice from summer 2025. We got so many support tickets that day, all asking why the calls suddenly sounded robotic. As Alex Hormozi says, "right now is the worst AI will ever be."
Today, I estimate that 80% of the people who call our franchise clients can't tell they're talking with AI, and the callers who catch it tend to be fairly tech-savvy.
Solve the caller's problem before you announce AI
Tommy asked if you have to tell callers they're talking with AI. Disclosure rules are changing state by state, so check with your lawyer. We tested this with a small franchise group by adding an opening line that said, in effect, "This is an AI assistant, but I can still help you," and callers started hanging up almost immediately.
"We have four times the hang up rates within the first 30 seconds."
We cut the disclosure right away and moved the questions that diagnose the caller's problem to the top of the script. Callers who got help in the first 30 seconds were far less likely to hang up, even when they figured out later that the agent was AI.
Tommy tested that approach live on the show by calling a demo agent for a junk removal company and asking for help clearing half his garage. The agent asked about the job, the junk and his contact details, and he stopped before giving his address.
"That's freaking killer. I liked it that you didn't say it's an agent."
Before you sign with any AI phone vendor, ask for a demo trained on your brand and try to break it. I tell doubtful executives that if they can break ours, I'll buy them lunch.
Text new leads, and get past customers to save your number
When Tommy asked about outbound AI calls, the law came first. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) is the federal law on robocalls and marketing texts, and in February 2024 the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the agency that enforces it, ruled that AI-generated voices count as "artificial" voices under the TCPA. That means an AI call needs the person's prior express consent.
Even with consent, most people won't pick up. Owners often want AI to call every web form lead the moment the form comes in, but nine times out of 10 a plain text message works better, because people ignore calls from numbers they don't know and far more of them reply to a text.
Tommy suggested that after every job, you automatically send the customer a vCard, a digital contact card, with a special line for past customers. The customer saves the card, so your number shows up on caller ID. Next time, they call that number instead of searching Google for you by name, a search known as a branded keyword, and clicking your pay-per-click ad, which charges you for every click.
"My branded keywords are just as much as non-branded, which is a pain in the butt because I do all the work."
Tommy already pays for the TV, radio and billboards that build that name, and Google charges him again when people search for it.
Fix your traffic before you fix your phones
The most common mistake I see is buying AI because everyone talks about it. A kitchen and interior remodeling franchise called us wanting "some AI in here," but when I asked how many calls each location got per day, the answer was five to 10.
"You are solving the wrong problem way too late or way too early."
A location that gets 10 calls a day and still misses some doesn't have a volume problem. It has a staffing problem, or a team that isn't picking up. Tommy pointed out that those remodeling jobs could run $60,000 each, which is exactly why a person should take those calls. Fix the staffing or the traffic first.
Find the problem before you build anything
Tommy also asked a question for his niece and two nephews, who are always building things but don't know what to do once they have.
"What would you tell somebody that they know how to build something, but they just don't know the next steps?"
Most young founders, me included early on, sell things just to make money, so they pick a product first and then go looking for buyers. Once I flipped that order, found a problem, figured out how to solve it and then sold the solution, my income went from $4,000 a month to $50,000 a month in about 90 days.
"Find a problem to solve before you build anything, before you even touch a computer."
Start by talking to people who run businesses.
Second, AI tools make building cheap and fast, so the product alone no longer sets you apart. Many of my friends are software developers who build impressive tools that go nowhere, because they don't know how to market them. Find a niche, find the person with the problem and find the message that gets them to buy. Then market the shit out of it.
Sell the rollout with a story, results and a spokesperson
When Tommy asked what he hadn't asked me yet, I went back to why new initiatives fail in a franchise network. I learned it from Joel Worthington at Mr. Electric, where he was brand president, and Mr. Electric belongs to Neighborly, a parent company of home service franchise brands. Nobody follows a new initiative if they can't see the vision, and that goes double for AI in a blue-collar industry, where some people are wary of it from the start.
- Lead with the story. Tell owners where the change takes them and why it matters to them, and not only to corporate.
- Back the story with results. A pilot program, a 30- to 60-day test with five to 10 locations, gives you real numbers before the whole network hears the pitch.
- Hand the mic to a spokesperson. A respected owner who lived the result gives peers a reason to believe.
At Superior Fence & Rail's annual conference in February, that spokesperson was Drew Raymond, whose franchise is one of the largest in the network and whom everyone respects. Drew stood up and said:
"Man, if this ain't the best thing since sliced bread, I don't know what is."
Because a peer said it, everyone around him had a reason to believe. Our guide to franchise rollouts covers the rest of the method.
Tommy took the lesson straight back to A1, where his team was pushing back on a new AI dispatching tool, and said he would get in front of it right away.
What franchise and home service leaders should take from this conversation
Even with 70 full-time agents, Tommy still backs up his people.
- Measure missed calls before you buy anything. Pull the missed-call number your reports leave out. If a location gets only a handful of calls a day, fix traffic or staffing before you buy AI.
- Put AI behind your best rep, and keep it off crisis calls. Staff your busiest hours with people, let AI catch the overflow, and solve the caller's problem in the first 30 seconds.
- Earn the rollout. Start with the story, prove it with pilot results and let a respected owner sell it to the network.
Watch the full conversation with Tommy
Watch the full episode with Tommy on YouTube, including the live demo call.
To hear how an agent trained on your brand handles your calls, try the NaiL voice demo.
Article by George Paladichuk, founder of NaiL. Featuring Tommy Mello, founder of A1 Garage Door Service and host of The Home Service Expert.
Want NaiL to handle your missed calls?
See how AI can convert more of your leads into booked jobs — 24/7.
Book a Free Demo