Back to Blog
AI Tools

Lisa Hudson Brought 26 Years at Macy's to a Painting Franchise. She Teaches Owners to Turn the Mirror on Themselves.

Fresh Coat Painters brand president Lisa Hudson on coaching yourself first, agreeing on a scoreboard, and saying the hard thing the same day.

George Paladichuk

George Paladichuk

Founder, NaiL

George Paladichuk and Lisa Hudson (left to right)

Featuring Lisa Hudson, brand president of Fresh Coat Painters.

Lisa Hudson puts accountability on the owner first, because the owner sets the standard and then enforces it. She checks her own behavior first, agrees on a scoreboard the team can see, and says the hard thing the day the gap appears. That method came out of 26 years in retail, and she now teaches it to painting franchise owners.

Lisa Hudson is the brand president of Fresh Coat Painters, a residential and commercial painting franchise with more than 180 locations. She came to painting after 26 years at Macy's, and 19 of those years she spent as a store manager. She worked in about 17 Macy's stores over those years, and the stores she ran did anywhere from $10 million to $72 million in sales.

She also owned a franchise with The Growth Coach, a business-coaching brand, and later became its president, so she has sat on both sides of a franchise agreement — the franchisee with one territory and the franchisor supporting a whole network.

Changing how an established brand sells inside a customer's home is one of the hardest jobs in franchising, so I invited Lisa to talk about it. She coaches owners with one line, which she used on our pre-show call: turn the mirror on yourself.

Turn the mirror on yourself before you look anywhere else

The habit started at Macy's with a real mirror.

"I used to have a mirror when you walked into work and said you're now on stage, right? You've got to leave your personal baggage at the door."

That mirror checked a store manager's game face, and the version Lisa coaches now points at results.

"if you really want to see a change in your business, you have to see a change in yourself first"

A franchisee has nobody upstairs to blame. When I asked Lisa to unpack the line, she said she had not noticed saying it, then went to the mechanics: a problem that keeps coming back means the diagnosis failed, because, as she put it, "we probably didn't dig deep enough to find the root cause. We just kind of put a Band-Aid on it, but then that Band-Aid washes off at some point."

The mirror means working on the business instead of working in it all day, and Lisa runs the exercise as three short lists: what to keep doing, what to think about doing, what to stop doing. Slowing down is the hard part, so she tells owners to recruit a coach, a peer or a neighbor who will slow them down.

Say the hard thing the same day, not three days later

A promotion made Lisa the boss of her own work friends, so she met the hardest version of the mirror early. Ignoring a behavior she did not want to see "doesn't help anyone," and holding someone accountable is especially hard in a small company, where Fresh Coat owners hire spouses, children, siblings and friends. What makes it hard is that "the risk is the relationship," and it can reach a whole family. Lisa checks herself first.

"is it will or skill? Have I invested enough in them? Am I being direct immediately, not three days later, not four days later? Am I giving tacit approval, which is seeing it and not saying anything?"

Tacit approval is the quiet item on that list, because an owner who sees a problem and stays silent for three days has approved it. Lisa also had to pull apart two judgments of her own, since "there's a difference between being great people and being the right fit for the business."

I hold the same line at my own company, where my partner is our customer success manager, family members have worked for us and college friends run much of our tech. Each of them carries the standard any other employee carries, because growth sets the standard and friendship does not. Sometimes the straight conversation even ends with a thank-you note.

"I've also got this weird file where I have had to help people move on and they thanked me for it later, so it's the thank you file"

Hiring slowly is the easier discipline, and Lisa says so plainly: "if you hire a little bit slower, then you don't have to fire as fast."

Give the team a scoreboard so accountability stops being personal

Lisa often hears franchisees say they left the corporate world to avoid holding people accountable.

"Well, it's kind of an excuse and it's a good one. It's a good excuse. And I also think it kind of indicates a fear. What I hear in that is I didn't know how to do it there and I don't know how to do it here."

The word accountable scares people, so she asks instead when an owner last had a great conversation with the employee about it, and how often the owner looks at the KPI, the key performance indicator that shows whether a role works. She treats that number the way an Indiana University fan treats a scoreboard.

"Numbers are numbers. Numbers don't lie, scoreboard doesn't lie."

Without a scoreboard every correction turns personal, so two rules keep the measures honest: owner and employee agree on them in advance, and the owner reviews them on a set rhythm, not in a bad week. Lisa also pushes leaders to ask what is in the employee's way, because a leader can fix a broken process upstream.

A scoreboard only helps an owner who can read the rest of the numbers, and plenty of franchise owners arrive from one function inside a big company, human resources or finance, then own every function at once. Reading a P&L, the profit and loss statement of what a business earned and spent, is a learned skill.

So Fresh Coat brought in Profit Soup, a financial trainer known in franchising for teaching "folks that have never had to do break even balance sheets, P&Ls before," and ran the session as Profit Rodeo at its national convention in Nashville. A break-even is the sales volume that covers costs.

"we really spent a lot of time making sure that your only number cannot just be your sales number"

Sales alone flatters an owner who loses money on every job, so Lisa walks owners through what a job costs to deliver and how many estimates a week the goal requires.

Nathan Willard, president of HOODZ and The Patch Boys, set aside a fixed weekly block for the P&L when he ran a location, the first of three habits that keep owners steady. Teaching a network new financial habits is a brand initiative like any other, and it turns on the sell-in — getting owners to adopt the change. Franchise rollouts fail more often on the sell-in than on the idea.

Win a skeptical system by listening first, then fix the easy things

Owners asked what a department store executive could know about painting. Lisa did not answer with a new sales process on day one: she went into the field, asked owners what they liked, what they did not and where they saw gaps, and asked permission before giving advice.

She fixed the quick things first and spent that credibility on the bigger chunks. What she carried over from retail was consistency, which she illustrates with a bag of fries.

"I love McDonald's French fries. I don't eat them very often, but when I do I want them to be a good McDonald's French fry."

Cold fries from a trusted brand do more damage than cold fries from a stranger, so one off day from one crew costs an owner that customer and the neighbor who sent her. Her standard, as she puts it, is that "everybody on the team has to know what direction we're rowing in" and stay consistent — a brand standard, not a pep talk.

Lisa also refuses to drive change by decree, because "telling is not going to work. Showing, influencing, asking the right questions to get movement." Joel Worthington ran the same play as president of Mr. Electric, where rebuilding franchisee trust came before any new system.

Make a national brand look local in every market

Brand recognition is one of the reasons owners buy a franchise, and that same recognition can leave every location looking identical. Fresh Coat's new VP of marketing noticed that every owner's website opened on the same cover page.

"the trees look different in Austin than they do in South Florida"

Stucco covers a lot of houses in some parts of the country, so the paint and the photographs change with the market, and Fresh Coat opened the website covers, the Google listings and several business practices for owners to customize.

A homeowner who meets an owner at a networking event now finds a local face instead of one more corporate template. Macy's ran the same idea through My Macy's, where each store carried a slightly different mix for the customer who shopped there.

Fresh Coat sells 14 refresh services aimed at what Lisa calls the stay-put economy, where homeowners stay in the house longer and reinvest instead of moving. Through Fresh Coat Cares, owners pick a charity in their own territory, and, in her words, "we help provide labor and Sherwin-Williams helps provide paint," so a repaint lands at a domestic violence center, a school or a camp.

The deepest local roots still come from ordinary life, because a logo on a youth baseball team puts a parent at the ballpark "several nights a week working without really working there," and in Lisa's words, "all of that's free advertising... That doesn't cost you a thing." Dan Antonelli argues the same case in trades brands that get five-mile famous.

Automate everything up to the front door, then put a person in the room

Lisa led The Growth Coach when COVID closed the rooms where its coaches won most of their clients face to face: chambers of commerce and BNI chapters, the referral groups where local owners pass each other leads.

Her team rebuilt the materials for video and taught a lot of people to use Zoom, which widened who one coach could reach. Her verdict fits any tool an owner keeps postponing: "I think there's a lot of businesses that can say during COVID, we tried something we should have tried, but we never did."

Fresh Coat now puts that comfort with software into its sales process. When one spouse misses the in-home estimate, the visit where a painter measures and quotes the work, the owner follows up with a Zoom call or a Loom, a short recorded proposal walkthrough.

Lisa draws her line at the front door, because everything up to the appointment can run on automation, down to the text that names who is coming, but inside the house a person has to sit down and let the customer raise objections. An objection signals interest, and a caller who clicks and hangs up never raises one.

Lisa jokes that "every woman in America has an Amazon board, a TikTok board, a Pinterest board," and a salesperson who ignores them misses the picture the customer already has in mind. By her own count, about 80% of Fresh Coat's in-home estimates happen with a woman, and her own rule for the follow-up is a count she credits to the stats.

"I think the average person makes a decision to buy after 9 to 12 touches. We live in America where it's three strikes and you're out, so we're all quitting way too early."

Automation covers most of the touches she counts without burning an owner's week, and Siro and Rilla record in-person sales conversations so owners can coach their reps, but nothing on the market paints a house. Lisa's guardrail is balance, because automation "does not replace the importance of relationships in your community," and I wrote up three ways operators get that balance wrong in how not to implement AI.

What franchise leaders and home service owners should take from Lisa's playbook

Lisa's method survived the move from a department store to a painting brand because it starts with the leader.

  • Coach yourself before you coach the team. Write Lisa's three lists — what to keep doing, what to think about doing, what to stop doing — then hand them to a coach or a peer who will ask about them next time.
  • Agree on the scoreboard before you need it. Set the measures for each role with the person who owns it, review them on a set rhythm, and open every gap conversation by asking what obstacle is in the way.
  • Hand each owner the parts of the brand the customer sees. Local photographs, local charities and local sponsorships belong to the owner, while the quality standards and the process stay with the brand.

Watch the episode and talk to Lisa

Watch the full episode with Lisa for her Macy's stories, the thank you file and more on Profit Rodeo. Lisa invites anyone curious about painting ownership to reach out on LinkedIn, and Fresh Coat's franchise site covers territories and the service mix.

To hear how an agent trained on your brand handles the calls your locations miss, try the NaiL voice demo.

Article by George Paladichuk, founder of NaiL. Featuring Lisa Hudson, brand president of Fresh Coat Painters.

Want NaiL to handle your missed calls?

See how AI can convert more of your leads into booked jobs — 24/7.

Book a Free Demo